Where’s the Magic in Modern Music?

I love music. Not all music, but at least some songs in nearly every genre. Especially what is loosely called “American roots” – early blues, ragtime, jazz, folk, rock, country, americana, gospel, and country, though within the past few years I branched out to French music hall and opera.  I don’t listen to much that was released after 1980. It isn’t that I dislike it, exactly, it just pales in comparison to the older stuff. Music used to be an art, and today it’s an industry.

The “best of the best” today isn’t in the same class with the old conjurors. There’s no soul in the music – nothing that grabs you way down inside and twists you up. We’ve got more sophisticated equipment and better quality instruments, but maybe modern producers are a little too zealous in making everything just perfect. Somewhere in all the mixing and dubbing, they edit the voodoo out.

For example, “Paper Planes” by MIA is a catchy, unique song, but everything about it is synthetic. That’s all right. Sometimes that’s okay.

But if you compare her to Geeshie Wiley or Blind Willie McTell… it’s far more than just the genres of music being different. Sort of like comparing a Bic lighter and a raging inferno.

Have you heard Mississippi John Hurt singing “Stack o’ Lee”? Somehow that old recording really brings back the killer’s cold, murderous presence  for a few moments. Mississippi John Hurt conjures up Stack o\’ Lee in 1928  It’s certainly not the work of a smooth producer; the recording is far from perfect, and you can hear Hurt clearing his throat several times.

Free MP3 downloads from the national archives – lots of free roots music mp3s here.
Is it unfair to dismiss modern artists as too plastic?

I get that it’s deliberate, but she is just scary looking

Probably: I only hear the songs that get airplay, for one, and new songs are played repeatedly on the radio until everyone gags when they hear the opening bars.

Of course, Hurt didn’t have the gift for self-promotion of, say, Lady GaGa, who had this to say about herself: “Speaking purely from a musical standpoint, I think I am a great performer. I am a talented entertainer. I consider myself to have one of the greatest voices in the industry. I consider myself to be one of the greatest songwriters.”

So my new mission is to find living singers/current songs who are as good as or better than the old stuff. I found some stuff I like: Ryan Adams, the Jayhawks, Blanche, Holly Golightly and the Brokeoffs, but the bar is set high and nobody’s topped it yet.


3 thoughts on “Where’s the Magic in Modern Music?

  1. Ruby,
    This is a great post. I spend most of my time listening to pre-1980 music as well, but good friends of mine have opened me up to new music that, despite it’s production, is just as substantial as the stuff of old. When you’re done with Ryan, check out Peter Case and Radiohead.

  2. Great post. There’s a lot to be said for not overproducing the shit out of songs, cleaning up, removing ‘noise’ – clearing of the throat and just that general overall ambience you speak of..it’s right. yeah it won’t satisy mr biggie biggs of biggie records but fuck him!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s